1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Homeschooling
Response to Letter to the Editor
Or...Unsympathetic Public School Teacher  
 
From:  KATHEBERT 
Dear Public School Teacher:
Have you ever burned your hand on the stove? When it happened, did you hold your hand there until the stove was cool enough for everyone to touch, or did you remove your hand so that further damage was not done? I can campaign for the betterment of our public schools without my children being exposed--"burned" if you like. Moreover, my children are an example in contrast (to anyone who will see) that there is a better way to teach children; and that we do have to guide our schools in that direction.
 
From:  DENHEN12  
I am a homeschooling mom with a year and a half under my belt. I teach my two daughters, aged 14 and 8. I am also a certified public school teacher with 10 years experience. I do feel that I have gained a unique perspective on this whole debate. I do feel a certain amount of sadness at the defensive attitudes I've seen displayed over the years (from both sides). When I was still in the system, I had several friends that taught their own children. Let me tell you, I had nothing but admiration for these families. Trying to defend their intentions and qualifications to my peers was a different story. Just because you hold a teaching certificate does not mean that you are qualified to teach. That comes from within, the love and compassion needed to teach children is a gift of God. The technique is really secondary. So I started to homeschool because I had a stroke that was caused by an illness called lupus. Since I was home, I didn't see a need for my children to go off to school. I, more than anyone, understood them and knew what they needed. There are many reasons to choose to homeschool. I've never heard one parent say that it was overcrowding. The public school teacher said, "Support us, and we will make schools better." What if we homeschool to provide character training and a knowledge of the goodness of God. How will this public school teacher provide that? Somehow we have got to get over the idea that homeschooling is weird and anti-American and only religious fanatics do it. To end this, my lupus is healed. Praise Jesus Christ! I'm still homeschooling. I hope this helps.
 
From:  DZESQ  
Gee, let's see. This teacher wants us to stop homeschooling because our kids get individual attention, and he wants us to put our kids in a class that is over crowded so they will NOT get individual attention, and he wants us to pay him more and spend all our time helping the school instead of taking care of our own family.

That sure sounds like an attractive offer!

Also, I wonder how giving him more money is going to make him less stressed out in his class. More importantly, I wonder how it is going to make me less stressed out.

Dave

 
From:  HEIMBACH1  
What would I say? For starters why bash ANYONE who takes on the awesome job of educating your children?

I think to want the kids in a loving setting and to give the best that home education can offer is to be commended. Most parents are teaching kids at different levels. you address each child's needs. Every parent has the right to educate their kids, some can't or simply do not want to...that is their chose. For those that do I say GOOD FOR YOU! It sounds like this teacher may be a bit on the jealous side, too bad. As for being underpaid, well I think most are paid too much, sorry that is how I feel. Our state gets over 5000.00 for each child enrolled and still more and more kids can't read, maybe if they stuck to the basics instead of this feel good ed. there just maybe a turnaround.

 
From:  UNVT  
The Public school. what a joke. it is so big that we do not even stand a chance at killing it. and this guy wants us to dump in more money into the deep dark pit of public education? give me a break. you want us to "donate" more money to a gigantic system that is failing? why? you think that because we choose to homeschool our kids that we are hiding them under a bushel. lets call it what it is. it is called preservation. if I sent my kids to the public school to learn the nazi agenda that our government has laid out for our children of this great nation to swallow, then everything that we have done for our kids as far as lighting their fire's for what we know as truth, would be drowned out. we would not need a bushel to put them under. what is so wrong with the preservation of innocence I ask you? why must we subject our children to all of the GARBAGE that the government has decided our children need to learn, when we as the parents should be deciding when our kids should be educated on sex! what ever happened to reading, writing, and arithmetic? the public school no longer teaches the basics! they have completely thrown all of that out of the window, and have gone to teaching social issues. Preservation! and as far as a home school mom being stressed out, what person doesn't feel stressed at times. we all do. no matter how we spend the day! it's just that we do not get to collect a wage, and nobody has an awards banquet for us and nobody pats us on the back. for that matter we are made fun of, thought strange and different all because we love our kids enough to give up our potential free time, benefits, wages, lunches, new clothes, maybe a bigger house, etc. etc. etc. we give all of those things up for what? for our kids. they are more than worth it! I will never ever ever put my kids into a public school so help me God! and it is called Preservation! christine
 
From:  Favrow 
My question is if that teacher is having the same problems we are then why is she/he on a homeschool forum.

There is a great forum on proteacher.
http://forums.about.com/n/main.asp?webtag=ab-homeschool&nav=messages&msg=1785.1
Try venting on that one you might get a little more sympathy there.
Michelle

 
From:  JENDAV53 
In response to the school teacher,
First of all I do not think there is a question that we think you are paid well for your job. You;re not. However I personally wrote to Governor Bush and received a form letter in return. I explained to him that I was not impressed with the public schools here and was thinking of home schooling. I understand the demands on you as a teacher and I agree that the schools are over crowded. All of which were included in my letter to him.

The reason I choose to home school however was the lack of respect for students and parents. I had my daughter in private school from pre-k to first grade. When my son was old enough to start pre-k we simply couldn't afford to have both in private so we opted for public. After enrolling them and finding out who my daughters teacher would be, I made a special appointment to meet her teacher before school started so I could explain my child's downfalls. She has a mild form of ADD and I wanted to be sure the teacher knew. I volunteered at that time to come in when ever she needed help in the class room. (not just with my daughter but in anyway she needed). My daughter started coming home with papers that she had no idea what to do with and when I asked her why she didn't know she replied that the teacher wouldn't explain it to her a second time and yelled at her for not listening. Upon confronting the teacher on this statement she said and I quote..."You need to have her tested for ADD" My jaw hit the floor! I had already TOLD her she had ADD and her particular type causes her to zone out. That was only the tip of the iceberg. My seven year old daughter wet her pants because they were not allowed to go to the bathroom except for designated times during the day. She has not wet her pants since she was 4. Not allowing them to go to the restroom can cause bladder infections as well as humiliate them when accidents happen.

Needless to say I met with the principal and the teachers and all they did was circle their wagons. So in response, yes we know that you are stressed and underpaid but when teachers start treating their students like human beings and not inconveniences maybe we will return to school. Until then as stressed as it makes us, at least we do it for love and not a paycheck.
Sincerely,
Deb Olszowka

 
From:  RAININGHERE   
I've been homeschooling/unschooling for not even an year now, and I can't stand the thought of going back to the world of harassment, boredom, and textbooks. I love teachers, I always have, but I requested to me taken out of school because I wasn't learning. Sure the crowded classrooms were bad, some of the preppy kids so to speak harassing me day in out was intolerable, and my friends not really my friends because I didn't have time to build deeper relationships with them. But that wasn't the problem. The problem was somewhere along the line I realized, the reason I suddenly went from being an underachiever in all of elementary school (climbing trees, playing, and doing chemistry experiments interested me more than homework), to being a straight A student in all of the 3 years of Middle school, wasn't because the school changed, or Middle School was more "comprehensive". It was because of me. I who developed goals in the summer and finished the coming years textbooks, me who read all the great science works, and then swiftly aced the tests. That was fine, you see. I gained the knowledge, sat through class, and got my A's, parent's no longer thinking I'm stupid. But there is a problem with all this. And it was that I was bored. The meaningless projects that were given with good intention, taught me nothing. All that busywork which was essentially just 'busy' work, was just sort of wasting my time. And I was loosing my brain knowledge, and gaining more 112 percents. Sometimes in math classes I would want them to slow down. And then in other classes, I had to sit and sit and sit waiting for others to finish, or more often, wait for the teacher to shut up, I get it! I know he doesn't get it, but I get it, and I would like to start on my homework now. Subjects that were fascinating written by Asimov, Darwin, or Shakespeare, became chores in textbooks that talked, how should I phrase it...baby-talk. But of course A's and praise give you sort of a glow of pride, that you shouldn't have because of a letter, that doesn't mean much when it comes to knowledge. But 8th grade was the last straw, A's were becoming normal and the minimum now, and I knew I wasn't learning as much as I could if I could spend my homework time reading, Mind's I. Most of all, my teacher's unlike before, weren't my friends, for some reason as I got in higher grades, there seemed to be more people, and my teacher's didn't seem to care for me like they use to. And classes reached a limit on wasting time (in lectures mostly because the boys in the back, and now next to me in the 2nd row as a punishment, were clowning around again <who can blame them?>), and projects that we've been doing every year since I don't remember when, homework that we learned nothing from, stress on the project about who invented the telephone, (didn't I do that in 3rd grade). American History was fascinating when I read that book in the summer, but boy was I wrong and so on. So I quit. Yup I quit. And now I've finished almost 3 years ahead of all the other students my age. No, not because of some miracle curriculum, turns out I knew quite a bit about science, so I could move on, and study more deeply. Since I've mastered the basics, my parent's let me coordinate my schedule and studies and stimulating projects (well to me!) on something I'm curious about.

School would be great, just keep everything, but requirements, more various textbooks, and no grade levels, perhaps more like brain levels. In my belief, when schools or learning in our society becomes a better place in accordance to human psychology and how we learn, like Grace Llewellyn says, "There would be a lot more library and a lot less school". Hey, nature made us to thus so far to design robots, and build bridges, naturally, every infant knows how to learn. While the rest of us may be full of facts, but learn slower because we've forgotten HOW to learn.

In support of Teacher's everywhere, and especially learning,
-Rain

Return to Article


Subscribe to the Newsletter
Name
Email

Talk about it in the Homeschooling Forum

  More About Homeschooling

Explore Homeschooling

About.com Special Features

A Smarter Future

Tips that will help finance your education, excel in the classroom, and advance your career. More >

How to Ace the GRE

Being well prepared is the first step; here are more essential suggestions. More >

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Homeschooling

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.