1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Homeschooling
Response to Letter to the Editor
Or...Unsympathetic Public School Teacher  
 
From:  PHILGALLO 
I have always appreciated the work that professional teachers have been asked to perform. I have been generally lucky, meeting very motivated and personally skilled individuals.

I am being driven to home schooling based upon the school system and it's inability to accommodate my child's personal requirements. I do understand the burden the school system bears and wish it was otherwise. I just cannot allow a child who is so motivated to self educate to be "bounced" out of a system that demands a "intellectual social conformance".

 
From:  BLAIRSPROUSE 
We had been in both worlds...homeschooling and public school. I have never doubted for one moment, as I am sure the thousands of parents tat are currently homeschooling, that teachers be it public private or home, give up everything for the good of the children. There is no doubt that you have worked week-ends, summers, holidays and never been paid for it. our children's Godmother is a teacher. She does not approve of what we doing with our children but that is her right. It is also our right to CHOOSE where our children go to school. As homeschooler we can still support our teachers of the public/private sector and contact leaders to better our school systems. No one is denying this. We are not "hiding" yet choosing an alternative. Do you live your life as I do? Am I condoning how you and others live? No! therefore if I so choose to homeschool my children then it should be you who supports these decision to make sure that everything is being done for my children as well. Working together, striving for one goal for our children. Allowing them the best education they can possibly get.

We had to enroll our children in public school this year due a difficult pregnancy and my Mother diagnosed with ovarian cancer (who died two weeks ago) decided that we could not at this time homeschool. A decision I wish that we would have NEVER made. Our children are bored and way ahead of the game. My straight A sixth grader grades dropped due to boredom. The first grader is just now doing what we were at the beginning of the year. I was promised that my children would get extra done for them yet never materialized. One teacher YELLED at me for getting my daughter so far into the school year she didn't know what to do with her. I have worked with them at home on the side and have been told to stop that it was interfering with her learning at school because she is once again way ahead. My children are not disruptive in class. Even the teachers tell us they wish they had classrooms of them. So we will bide our time to the end of school and prayer that next year will be better. Oh, by the way...I volunteer a ton of time trying to make a difference in their classrooms. Instead I am seeing teachers fooling around, wasting time, yelling at children that they can not get to behave. What a wonderful learning environment. Your right, I should have my kids in this learning environment rather at home where yes, the are times of frustration and tears but also love, one on one time, and the feeling of accomplishment. My children have had to endure problems with teasing of those in public school but 9 times out of 10 the response is "Gee, I wish my Mom would do that for me" or "can I start coming to your house for school?". Every job has it ups and downs, whiners and complainers...why is it that we hear more on this level from teachers than any other profession? I am a social worker, but do you hear me complain of the clients, low pay and the fact that I could qualify for federal and state assistance if I applied? Do you hear how I to work weekends-and holidays to make sure that my patients have a place to live or medication? No. So please step down, take note that God has given you a wonderful gift in working with beautiful children. There are people you will never approve of whether it be their religion, lifestyle or even the way the talk. So instead of complaining why not take the time to learn about them, reach out and embrace them. You might actually see that there is something there after all.

 
From:  KUNZE5 
I have to say it that exact lousy attitude that parents are pulling their children from public school and homeschooling. Speaking loudly or quietly or repeatedly to public school teachers, principals etc is useless. I personally have been at that battle for the last school and as a result of inadequate communication (after multiple attempts on my part) and obviously no resolution to the problem(s), I am pulling my son from public school on Monday and homeschooling the remainder of the year. It may or may not continue into the next year, I don't know. But I can guarantee you this, until teachers and other public school officials actually listen to parents and take their concerns seriously, the trend to homeschooling will continue to skyrocket. Teachers and other school officials need to stop thinking about themselves and what is best for the children. Don't put the responsibility of thinking of all the kids onto one parent. It is the parents responsibility to think of their child's best interests. Yes, their are going to be conflicts. But schools need to start listening and stop spouting off on how underpaid and overcrowded they are in the classrooms. At least the parents are taking action when they chose to homeschool their child. The ones still whining are part of the problem. Action equals results.
 
From:  LYNNB21 
I for one tried for years to work with several schools, through teachers and school boards to make schools a better (especially around safety issues and mistreatment by 'overworked teachers') to no avail, usually informed that the issues were the norms of society and my kids would have to deal with it, as the would in the work world.

You do sound like a very overworked teacher but as I see it you have more influence as a teacher on the political side of the issue than any parent or child will ever have.

I think you should get out of teaching now as I have seen it change teachers for the worse.

I have yet to meet a homeschooling parent (moans and groans being part of our dealing with others expectations just as much as anything else), who pass their stresses onto their children. But I have experienced many teachers transfer their stress onto their pupils.

It took me 15 years of having 5 children in the system before I realized they did not have to suffer.

You on the other hand must know that you have other options.

I do wish you all the best as I know I could not personally at this stage in my life return to dealing with upwards of 30 energetic young people in one room,

Lynn

 
From:  Moises3
I am a public H. S. teacher for ten years now and I think homeschooling is great! My cousin had to pull her two sons out after they kept getting beaten up for not having the right shoes. She did real well with them. Homeschooling is a good option for some people.

In fact, I recommend it for some. Public school teaching is low paid and all the other complaints that go with it are true too. Instead of griping about it, maybe some p.s. teachers should look for another job. Homeschooling can only be a godsend however; I say thank you to homeschooling parents/guardians. Not that many are doing it my job is in no danger.

 
From:  KRISSYZ40 
Well, I understand her frustration. low pay, large classrooms, smart alec kids these days...I think we as parents are ALWAYS teaching, and get just as frustrated, so in addition to daily life, we must teach them academics. I think her vent was not so much towards YOU or the article, but more frustration for what she seems to be facing. Yes, she has a point, and we should stand up for kids and higher paid teachers, but that does not always influence the reasons for teaching at home. They BOTH can have their benefits, they BOTH can have their downfalls and frustrations. You have to take the good with the bad and do it for the love of the job as well as the child.
Krissy
 
From:  MOMMTO3KIDS 
I am sorry if you feel like your job eats into your personal life and intrudes into your family time. That was your choice. You CHOSE to be a teacher. Just as teachers need a "pick me up" pep-talk sometimes, so do homeschool teachers. Those of us who homeschool do not agree with things that go on in public education. Do you? I have never met a teacher who did. However, that is your job. So, you make the best of it.

On your idea about voicing our opinions for all children. (Because that would work and you know how our government always listens and works so fast! sarcasm) What are we supposed to do, let our children fall behind, loose interest in learning, etc, while we WAIT for the government to change things? The government ALWAYS has red tape to go through, and that can take years.

I went to school to be a teacher, I have a teaching license. Once I had my first son, I decided that I wanted to teach my own children. I CHOSE for this to BE my part of my personal and family life. I am so PROUD of my children and my teaching them. In all honesty, even if schools were perfect, I would still want to do this. It doesn't bother me that you feel no sympathy for homeschoolers. I don't want or need your sympathy. But I am glad that I can get help and understanding from other homeschoolers.
Sincerely,
A. P. - from Oklahoma

 
From:  ALANSBRAT 
To the unsympathetic teacher - I did not pull my children out of the public school system because of "bad" teachers. I pulled them out because they were the best teachers around, and they still couldn't adequately address my children's needs - which the teacher(s) recognized. To quote one of them, "Sometimes I look at your daughter, and I think of what I am stifling every day, and I feel guilty and inadequate."

While you may think that I should have "stayed in the system" and fought to have what my children need provided by the public schools, MY CHILDREN ONLY HAVE ONE CHILDHOOD. Yes, I agree that more teachers would help - but while we try to change the system I will NOT sit by and watch my children lose precious years of education.

Thank you for staying in the game for all those parents who don't have or don't choose other options - hopefully one day the school system will work for ALL children.

Return to Article


Subscribe to the Newsletter
Name
Email

Talk about it in the Homeschooling Forum

  More About Homeschooling

Explore Homeschooling

More from About.com

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Homeschooling

©2008 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.