Homeschooling

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Homeschooling
Response to Letter to the Editor
Or...Unsympathetic Public School Teacher  
 
From:  Indigomom
This is in response to the unsympathetic school teacher. First of all, the post you responded to is one that could apply to any parent. Not just homeschoolers. We all get overwhelmed at times. Wither it's assisting with homework, school projects, helping to prepare for exams or homeschooling. You see any parent who is actively raising children is a very busy person. Your issues shouldn't be with us for having a vested interest in the education of our children, but with the parents you deal with who think the education of their children begins and ends with you, as if it is solely your responsibility. As for us only being concerned with our own children, the existence of the forum you posted on is obviously a disclaimer to that commentary. This board exists for us to share ideas and concerns. We've all asked questions and received suggestions from strangers with nothing more in common than our love and dedication to our children. I think you should check into your local homeschool organization and meet some of the people involved. You might even be able to offer some ideas to assist in the learning of children and parents who are actually interested in learning. You might even find a few ideas you could apply to your teaching as well, like you said, we have an idea of what you go through. I hope you soon find the joy through the frustration. And when you find it difficult I'm sure you can come to this board for a reminder of where to look for it. The true joy isn't so much in the teaching...it's in watching the children learn.

One other thing. If the rise in parents choosing to homeschool their children isn't a loud cry to the politicians governing the standard of education offered to our children, maybe no one is even listening.

 
From:  cfaguy
I have and always have had a great deal of respect for teachers. I believe that the work that they do is invaluable. I am of the opinion that they are grossly underpaid for the work that they do and that it is unfair to blame them all for the actions of the few.

I have many friends and family members who are teachers and I know the work that goes on behind. However, not all teachers are worth their weight in salt.

While I agree that we should raise our voices against the educational system and try to bring about reform, I am not about to sacrifice my children, their sense of self, and their education to a lousy system. By the time reform can be brought about my children will have gone through a system that does not work. This, I am not willing to do.

I also believe that I am the best person to teach my children in the sanctity of our home. It is a safe environment for them to learn. They learn at their own pace and they are able to make some decisions as to what they learn. Hence to use the jargon of the day, they are empowered. They want to learn, even if it happens in a non-traditional manner.

I am, however, fed up with teachers who come down on we homeschoolers for doing what we believe is the best thing for our children. I do not question your choices, kindly show me the same respect.

 
From:  MEDICMOM 
Dear stressed out public school teacher,

After reading your response to the article, "Help! I can't take it anymore!", I felt that the subtitle, "How to lighten the load and prevent burnout" was a more appropriate title for the article that Mrs. Hernandez wrote. Also, while reading your response, I feel that it may be helpful for you to take her advise. You sound just as stressed as some of us do at times. Also, many homeschool moms have full or part time jobs and can relate to job burnout as well as teacher burnout. You are obviously suffering from both and I am glad that my child is not subjected to attitudes such as yours. I have been homeschooling my daughter for two years now. The reasons that I pulled her from public school are listed below.

1. She was spending 7 hours a day in public school and still brought home 2-3 hours of homework every night (in the second grade).
2. She was being exposed to "negative socialization" as I have so appropriately labeled it. Her attitude was terrible and she was bringing home words that I didn't learn until I was in high school.
3. She was being exposed to sexual misconduct (in the second grade) which was addressed to the school officials on more than one occasion with nothing being done about it.
4. She cried before going to school almost every morning and was obviously suffering from needless anxiety and stresses that a second grader need not have to deal with.
5. She was failing math.
6. Reading comprehension was below grade level.

My daughter is now in the 4th grade and we are nearing the end of our second year teaching at home. Her attitude has greatly improved. Stress level is down. We finish our lessons in 3-4 hours a day. Instead of being exposed to the negative aspects of socialization she is surrounded by a loving environment with respect, morals and values as our focus along with, of course, prayer and our Lord. Math grades are at grade level. I just had her reading tested and she is reading on the 8th grade level. Way to go homeschooler!!! You should really think twice before pounding the homeschool moms. I am sure that most of us tried to change things before electing to take the measures that we did. I may not know what your teaching environment is all about but I do know mine and I am thankful that we have been given the chance to learn at home. One last thing.....Comments made by people like you are what gives me the encouragement to continue teaching my child at home. So thanks again to a stressed out public school teacher for snapping me back to reality and reminding me that making lesson plans, teaching, being the taxi, the mom, the housekeeper, the wife and the cook is not so bad after all. I will include you in my prayer tonight.

Sincerely,
S. Taylor

.........that is what I would tell this person. ;)

 
From:  MOMMY2FOUR 
I had the wonderful opportunity of sending two of my children to a Department of Defense school. Each would come home bubbling with information that they had learned that day. Then through unfortunate circumstances, we left the military and had to enroll our children in PS.

WOW, big difference, I'm sad to say! My oldest lasted 1 year and 2 months in the public schools. The straw that broke the camel's back was when I was sitting with my son around a table full of his middle school teachers, and the school "PSYCHOLOGIST" getting in his face and telling him what a rotten kid he was...

Well, my son was angry, depressed...I have holes in my wall from where he's kicked them in. As soon as I pulled him out I realized the problem, in such a short amount of time he was completely DUMBED DOWN. It was as if he just shut his brain down and was on auto pilot. A kid who could read before kindergarten and had an insatiable appetite for learning, lost all desire to even live.

I'm happy to say that my son is getting back on track. He does not loathe math anymore (he was doing 3rd grade work in 1st grade). I have been warned by our local support group that it may take up to 2 years to undo what the PS has done to him...I only pray it happens that fast. He no longer talks about killing himself and hits himself in the head screaming "I'm stupid!".

I found the article quite helpful, I even started using some of the suggestions this morning! But with the exception of a very few, you can't tell me that teachers care more about our kids than we do...although the system is in the process of making parents believe that they are incapable of raising their own children

I fear that the situation is only going to get worse, as the caring parents pull their kids out, you're going to be left with the kids whose parents could care less if their children get an education or not. And another trend that I noticed is that when a job opened up for a teacher on the military post, the PS teacher would drop everything and run for the job. I wonder why?

Keep fighting the fight!

 
From:  CINDARELLA12 
I just read the letter from the unsympathetic teacher and could relate to her feelings of frustration, but don't understand her reaction. I was a teacher for 5 years 2 of which were in Florida. I've never had a more stressful job in my life than the two years I taught in Florida. The classes are overcrowded and you do not have any support from your administration on discipline problems. Their main goal is to keep their referrals down so as to make sure they get all their funding for next year, so if you have problems you feel that you have no where to turn and the children also know that there is no consequences for their actions. Most of your day is used up disciplining the behavior problems, while the ones that are there to learn miss out on quality learning. I had three parents pull their children out of my class to homeschool because of this frustration. This did not bother me, because I knew that they would get more attention at home that I was unable to give them in class. Maybe when the school system wakes up and realizes that education is not all about test scores and money then the system will improve. We are getting together and showing them that we will not stand for anymore ignorance when it comes to our children, we are demanding more. Our children will get a better education at home until the government realizes that schools need a complete overhaul. I got so frustrated as a teacher I resigned and pulled my four children (7,9,10,11) out and now homeschool them. My son who was held back in 3rd grade last year is now working on a 6th grade level. My only worry about homeschooling is that they get so far advanced of children in public school, I do not want my children to graduate that early but at the rate they are learning at home it is bound to happen. They have in 3 months learned more at home than they did their whole education in the public school system.
 
From:  CINDARELLA12 
Teachers work more than 40 hours a week we work 24 hours a day 7 days a week.
 
From:  hmknz   
As an experienced elementary teacher who is now homeschooling I fully understand the pressures and stress of teachers in public schools. Teachers these days, are expected to not only teach the academic subjects required but now, due to many changes in society in general, teachers are expected to be social workers, establishers or moral systems, and yes, even teaching life skills which up until recently were the responsibility of parents. However, the lobbying of local governments and Education establishments has proven to be a dead end with students and teachers continuing to be pressurized, twisted, pulled and pushed in all directions while current directors and trustees decide what might be good for their school future. Schools, districts and boards do have their own private agendas and these often do not represent the best for the students. There is no need for sarcasm nor is there any need for finger pointing to homeschoolers as 'hiding their lights under bushels'. It is every parents' right to ensure their child/ren receive/s the best education possible and in these times where 'anything goes' a well balanced home education is most profitable and rewarding for the thousands of families currently doing so. Planning and good time management skills are vital as are realistic goals and aspirations.

Congratulations to PS teachers for 'keeping on' and congratulations to home educators for 'keeping on'. It is wise to know your curriculum and goals and to be firm in the education style/format/route you have chosen, rather than being tossed about in the winds/whims of change according to some 'harebrain' schemes 'for the good of the school'

Ultimately, we are on the lookout 'for the good of our children' and I challenge all parents to do this and be satisfied with their choice.
heather

 
From:  BLUESCLUE 
I realized by your letter that people do not appreciate teachers and all the effort they put into their profession. This is sad but true. I admire, respect teachers in private as well as public schools. Especially those teaching in public schools. I took my 2 boys out of private school in midyear this Jan.. I reached out to the school for the last 3 years and offered my time to start up things for the students who were advanced. After talking to the everyone in the school that mattered in the decision making, I got nothing back. I tried the gifted programs in the public schools and it was good but I wanted my children to be in a atmosphere where Christ would be taught and lived out. I realized that paying all that money for private school while I was at home doing extra work with my children to keep them from thinking that learning was boring, not challenging and no rewards at the end, I didn't have enough time in the day after school to do this. All in all, homeschooling was in my heart for a while and it was time. I tried to get the school involved but no response. I hear what you are saying and I once taught at public school, my sister is a teacher in a pub. school, my sister-in-law is a teacher at a public school and so are 3 of my friends. I know how you must be feeling. I didn't take my kids out for them only. I felt that I gave it enough time and money. I have been only homeschooling for 2 months now and it is not easy. But, the joy I get from watching my boys learn and see in their eyes the excitement to learn, homeschool wins, hands down. Please don't think that the homeschooling people are selfish or don't care about the world and the people in it. We do care and our children are in the world and we need to guide them the way we feel is right as their parents. I have many friends whose children are still in school and doing great. I never thought that homeschooling is better than school. I just found God drawing me closer to homeschooling my children. In the 2 months with them 24/7, I have found peace, joy, and excitement even though I have rough days where no one wants to study or concentrate. During those times, we just get books out and read to each other, play scrabble, or do trivia topics. That is the positive to homeschooling. We are flexible to see our own students needs as well as our needs. Lots of luck to you and I do understand the frustration on your part. Hang in there and remember that God is the ultimate rewarder and the judge. God bless.
 
From:  ICEY1234 
This teacher told me volumes about him/herself by his/her letter.
Sometimes a short and simple response is best.
"I'm surprised you take my h/s as a personal attack."

Return to Article


Subscribe to the Newsletter
Name
Email

Talk about it in the Homeschooling Forum

  More About Homeschooling

Explore Homeschooling

About.com Special Features

Homeschooling

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Homeschooling

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.