Homeschooling

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Homeschooling
Response to Letter to the Editor
Or...Unsympathetic Public School Teacher  
 
From:  SCARR07 
I agree to a degree. I think what most teachers don't realize is that we do respect and admire them. Just as in all professions, there are some burnt out teachers, and just some plain bad apples. However, this is a free choice we make, and all for various reasons. I homeschooled so we could travel! Also, another reason wasn't so much the teachers, but the whole public school scene, and we couldn't afford Christian school. It's a complex problem and if the training would start in the home, then all would be better off. And isn't that what we're doing? Training them at home? God Bless, Sandy
 
From:  CYNTHIA4693 
How dare you? How many children have you given birth to, D.G.? Or come home after having given birth to care for another child, and a spouse, and a home, D.G.? How many children do you even have? Any? And if so, I'd be willing to bet that it's your wife who does the majority of the staying up with them when they are ill, cleaning vomit off the floor at 3 AM, or "taxi-ing" them around, or taking them to the doctor, or the dentist, ad nauseam. I'll bet you send disciplinary problems to the principal, don't you, D.G.? I'll bet you get a lunch break, D.G. I'll bet you get summers off, D.G. I'll bet your class doesn't go to the grocery store or the dry cleaners or the veterinarian's office with you, do they, D.G.? I'd even be willing to bet you even get to go to the bathroom in relative peace. And yet you still find enough rancor for homeschooling parents to lash out like you did in your letter... You need to re-educate yourself, D.G.. Yes, overcrowding is a problem, but so are angry, bitter teachers who cannot see past their personal issues to the individual child's needs. I liken the situation to this - the schools are at best limping along. If the brakes on a bus were only working part of the time, I wouldn't entrust our lives to the possibility they MIGHT work. Rather, I'd be proactive and take a cab. Homeschooling is that educational "cab." My children are learning here and now (might I add without the added pressures of drugs or violence). I don't have (nor do they have) the luxury of waiting around for the system to change. It won't - not in their educational lifetimes. The only way the system ever changes is when it starts to crumble under the weight of its own inequities. Perhaps you SHOULD find some sympathy, or at least empathy, for a sometimes tired homeschool mom, who is picking up the slack for a jaded, bitter teacher like yourself. Homeschooling is a calling - EVERY homeschool parent I know does it for the love and concern for their children's hearts AND minds. I wish I could say the same for every teacher I'd ever met.

And P.S. - "Slagging" is not a word. You might want to check your grammar, too - not a stellar example of the "dedicated" teachers out there.

 
From:  NHG 
Dear Frustrated Teacher,

Believe me, my heart goes out to underpaid, overworked, stressed out teachers. I am a psychologist, and several of my favorite patients are teachers. Your thoughts about being an advocate for all children, voicing complaints to the govt. etc. are sound in theory. You miss, however, the main point. This will, at best, take years to correct--NOT at the expense of my child, thank you very much. When my gifted daughter in second grade was being forced to read books and discuss them for weeks, when she had read them at four, it was too personal a problem to be a political activist. We were rapidly losing her enthusiasm for learning, and the school system's "gifted" program did not start until fourth grade, and should have been called "bright average, compliant, and lots of homework". With homeschooling parents, you're "preaching to the choir" about all the public school problems and frustrations, however if I have the means, and yes, the ability to make the great sacrifices to provide my daughter the higher level of enriched learning she requires, and YES, lots more groups of kids to interact and thrive with, I will do that, even if it is deemed selfish by some. If you had a relative dying of cancer, are you going to concentrate all your resources seeking the best treatment, or go out and campaign against smoking? NHG

 
From:  KIDSRSUPR 
I had so many mixed feelings from your post it's hard to know where to begin. Of course home schooling teachers know how difficult it is in public school. There are more issues at hand than just low pay etc. What about the discipline problems? Besides my daughter being the target of a very, very unhappy woman, she had to put up with really rotten children that got away with way too much. There is no control in school. The principal tried to cover up for the teacher and all the discipline problems. We can scream about all the problems with the public education system AFTER people get their act together and teach there children respect, morals, etc. at home. Without that, the teachers don't have a chance.

There is always two sides to the story. Just like public school teachers, home school teachers have good and bad days. Some public school teachers are wonderful, some are horrible. I just don't feel like taking the chance again. My daughter is still not back to herself after her experience and it's been almost a year.

I hope I was able to get my point across.

A mom loving home schooling,
Doreen

 
From:  RONBATES1 
Since most of the replies to this misinformed schoolteacher have been from women, please allow me to present a gentleman's perspective. I wish that I could pay my wife half of what this super-literate rocket scientist makes. She would be worth every penny. Instead I work very hard to pay my taxes, so that my children can't take advantage of my tax money. Additionally, I am in the military, and have fought in 3 different theatres, so that my family has the right to choose homeschooling or PS. My children have never attended PS, and we pray to God they never will. The list of reasons why we choose not to enroll them is too extensive for this forum. But, once again, this "teacher" has given credence to my fears. If pulling your children out of PS exacerbates their problems, that doesn't say very much for you as a parent or a teacher. As for teacher's pay, I'd take it over my salary any day, but as we are both shot at doing our jobs, your pay might be commensurate. We do stand up for other kids, we beg and plead with their parents to homeschool them. We have "turned" many a family to "the dark-side!" I know teachers have one arm tied behind their backs, but I only had 2 teachers that ever impressed me with their abilities. As far as raising my voice to government, you bet! Once HS really takes off, I will lobby for legislation relieving me of paying taxes for a service I never intend to use. In the Army we have an expression when your Rucksack gets too heavy. We turn to our buddy and say, "Get this big green tick off of me!" That's how our family feels about PS. Sorry. God Bless all of you though for trying. My prayers go out to the children whose parents don't HS. MY SYMPATHIES go to the teachers who get paid to teach, and whine about it. It must be hard to get up every morning with such a horrible job that eats into your personal life. The next time you feel a big "whine session" coming on, carry your behind on down to the recruiters station and sign on the dotted line. They'll make your problems float away in a sea of agonizing pain, where you will learn to work 24/7 for Uncle Sam. Think about it. Oh, by the way, I go to work every day with the biggest grin you've ever seen! God keeps me here so you can continue to cry in open chat rooms instead of working in a grain field/sweat shop for the Government. Sweet Dreams Comrade!
 
From:  SAMIAMINUSA 
I am so sorry to hear the anger in the message to Bev. I feel even sorrier though for the school children that are unfortunately exposed to such a negative person every day!

I, too am a school teacher. I WAS teaching at my daughter's PRIVATE CHRISTIAN school when after the first semester I had to make some major changes in our whole lifestyle!

I saw my children going "without" every day just so that I could "Be all that I could be" for everyone else. I love working with children and I do realize that there are people in the teaching profession that do not earn enough money financially to become independent. However, that is no excuse to sit back and do nothing.

If you have chosen this profession, you did so with full knowledge that it is more of a sacrificial job than many other lay person jobs. Hopefully you entered this noble profession to make a difference in the mind of a young person. Or maybe you chose this profession to have a grasp on the youth of tomorrow, and have the ability to mold a young person's character. Only you can answer this, however, I applaud your initiative, it just sounds sadly as if you are "Burned out!"

Maybe if you could focus on why you began this career, and realized what you are giving, instead of what you are NOT receiving you may be a much more satisfied person.

I personally chose to leave for my children, who were physically always sick, they were tired of being dragged around to school and different meetings, and I saw that my family life made a drastic turn towards upheaval! I did not make this decision without regret and even remorse at leaving the children behind, however, I did have to do the more appropriate thing for my own family's sake. I can gladly say today I know without the shadow of a doubt I made the right choice. It is a sacrifice. We do without in a lot of areas because we are not having a second income, however, my husband and I felt it was/is our family first.

This is not about me however, and I fear it sounds as if you have already begun to be so cynical that you may not receive this in the way it is intended. I do care for the education of America's children. I do believe some teacher's are overworked, and underpaid. I have seen first hand what can happen to the luster in the eagle eye of a teacher when they begin to slip into remorse. I have seen great teachers become horribly dull, cynical and even abusive to their once loved students. I hope you are not in this category. I have seen children at school being verbally abused, simply because the teacher was having a BAD day. Is that fair? Absolutely No! However, it happens more than I care to say. Somewhere between the days, years, and so on, I guess they simply forgot what they were there for in the first place. It certainly wasn't to be a millionaire!

I also believe that we are the product of what we see and believe about ourselves. No matter what your circumstances you have a choice in how you react to them. You can either become negative, unfeeling, and simply puffed up with resentment. Or you can find something to be glad and rejoice about in all things great or small, and find the silver lining in every rainbow. I choose to think the cup is half full, what do you think?

Sincerely,
A new homeschool Mom with a love for the Lord in my heart!

 
From:  RDCOBB 
As a sympathetic school teacher and a husband to a homeschooling mother, I am bothered by the response this teacher gave you to your letter. First of all, I count no fewer than 5 grammatical mistakes in the letter. Poor writing skills are not the best argument for public schools. Second, to assume that criticism of schools with overcrowded classrooms equals criticism of teachers is false. I know that we can improve the system; however, this is not an indictment on my classroom performance. Most reasonable people believe that the majority of teachers do the best they can. Finally, I'm proud of my wife for wanting to homeschool our children. It shows an extra level of dedication that far too often families now lack. Bravo!
 
From:  EHACK30  
I was a ps teacher before I became a hsing parent. I must say that parents and teachers have been trying to change the system for a ling time. I even know of hsing parents who are still trying to change the ps system, but the system has gotten worse, not better. To blame parents for wanting better for their children than ps, is just wrong. Also I must point out that many parents, myself included, have different reasons for hsing. Last but not least how is the choice to hs any different than choosing private school? I feel the need to stand up for my child first and other children second because they were entrusted to me and no one else! I don't believe that it takes a village to raise a child, but a caring, functional family to raise a child!
 
From:  DE7INHIM1 
Dear Unsympathetic Teacher??
First, let's discuss your grammar and sentence construction??? Second, don't you have better things to do with your precious free time? What kind of teacher takes the time to criticize a dedicated mom, who is laying her life on the line daily for her family?? I say...got any words of encouragement?? If not....get a life.

Return to Article


Subscribe to the Newsletter
Name
Email

Talk about it in the Homeschooling Forum

  More About Homeschooling

Explore Homeschooling

About.com Special Features

Homeschooling

  1. Home
  2. Education
  3. Homeschooling

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.